Skip to content
Sign up

Melbourne, Victoria · October 2026 figures

Compare the top 10 Italian restaurants in Melbourne, VIC

Of the top 10, Shanikas Berwick has the most reviews (3,212), and 4 of them share the highest average (5.0). Rebello - A Slice of Italy lists the most opening hours of the 10 (96 a week).

The top 10 Italian restaurants in Melbourne, side by side
RankBusinessRatingReviewsRating floorDays openSaturdaySundayOpen latePhoneWebsite
1Straight Outta NaplesMaidstone5.0124Floor 4.857YesYesYes(03) 9689 1954straightouttanaples.com.au
2Buono Restaurant & BarParkdale4.9732Floor 4.846YesYesYes(03) 8510 5246buonoparkdale.com.au
3Rebello - A Slice of ItalyAlbert Park4.9517Floor 4.837YesYesYes(03) 9191 1218rebello.au
4Mr. Grill Burger & ParmaBentleigh5.082Floor 4.826YesYesYes(03) 8394 4036mrgrillburgerandparma.com.au
5Anima QCarlton5.077Floor 4.815YesNoYes(03) 7300 6632animaq.com.au
6Borgo Food & WineAscot Vale4.9218Floor 4.795YesNoYes(03) 8436 1949borgofoodandwine.com.au
7Shanikas BerwickBerwick4.83,212Floor 4.777YesYesYes(03) 9707 3511shanikas.com.au
8RoccellaEast Melbourne4.83,094Floor 4.777YesYesYes(03) 9416 1700roccellaitalian.com.au/east-melbourne
9Sincero Ristorante & BarMalvern4.9140Floor 4.765YesNoYes(03) 8527 5753sincero.com.au
10Pasta FornaRowville5.045Floor 4.753YesNoNo0419 383 421pastaforna.com.au

See all 483 ranked

More in Melbourne

Italian Restaurants elsewhere in Victoria

Ratings and review counts are Google's, as listed in October 2026. Phone numbers, websites and opening hours are the ones each business lists. Nothing here is paid for or verified by Calso. How the ranking works.