Newcastle, New South Wales · October 2026 figures
Compare the top 10 pizza restaurants in Newcastle, NSW
Pauly's Gourmet Kitchen has the most reviews (472), and Just One More Pizza the highest average (5.0 from 53 reviews). 3 Sicilians Ristorante lists the most opening hours (46 a week).
| Rank | Business | Rating | Reviews | Rating floor | Days open | Saturday | Sunday | Open late | Phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Just One More PizzaRothbury | 5.0 | 53 | Floor 4.77 | 4 | Yes | No | No | 0421 215 634 | none listed |
| 2 | 3 Sicilians RistoranteStockton | 4.8 | 408 | Floor 4.72 | 7 | Yes | Yes | No | (02) 4967 9065 | 3sicilians.com |
| 3 | Fermento Pizza JointMayfield West | 4.9 | 70 | Floor 4.70 | 5 | Yes | No | No | (02) 4706 8304 | fermentopizza.com.au/home |
| 4 | Pauly's Gourmet KitchenMorisset | 4.7 | 472 | Floor 4.62 | 6 | Yes | Yes | Yes | (02) 4973 2566 | none listed |
| 5 | Bar SolèTighes Hill | 4.7 | 178 | Floor 4.58 | 5 | Yes | Yes | Yes | 0413 426 124 | none listed |
| 6 | Harry's Gourmet PizzaAdamstown | 4.6 | 210 | Floor 4.49 | 7 | Yes | Yes | Yes | (02) 4953 9383 | harrysgourmetpizza.com.au |
| 7 | Lukey D's Detroit Style PizzaEdgeworth | 4.8 | 25 | Floor 4.47 | not listed | not listed | not listed | not listed | 0406 140 437 | lukeyds.com |
| 8 | G Pizza MayfieldMayfield | 4.6 | 106 | Floor 4.44 | 6 | Yes | Yes | Yes | (02) 4904 4111 | gpizza.com.au |
| 9 | DiRoma PizzeriaMerewether | 4.5 | 334 | Floor 4.41 | 5 | Yes | Yes | No | (02) 4961 4441 | diroma.com.au |
| 10 | Pilgrim's PizzasBoolaroo | 4.6 | 69 | Floor 4.40 | 5 | Yes | Yes | No | (02) 4943 2257 | pilgrimspizzas.com |
More in Newcastle
- Cafes378 ranked
- Mechanics285 ranked
- Hair Salons276 ranked
- Restaurants276 ranked
- Gyms221 ranked
- Beauty Salons203 ranked
- GP Clinics & Medical Centres173 ranked
- Massage Therapists172 ranked
- Real Estate Agents171 ranked
- Childcare Centres166 ranked
- Electricians166 ranked
- Holiday Homes, Apartments & B&Bs164 ranked
- Builders & Trades147 ranked
- Supermarkets & Grocers144 ranked
- Plumbers130 ranked
- Law Firms & Legal Services128 ranked
- Bars & Pubs111 ranked
- Gardeners & Landscapers111 ranked
- Dentists107 ranked
- Pharmacies104 ranked
- Fast Food & Chicken Shops98 ranked
- Barbers97 ranked
- Clothing & Fashion Stores97 ranked
- Hotels & Resorts97 ranked
Pizza Restaurants elsewhere in New South Wales
- Pizza Restaurants in Sydney847 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Central Coast67 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Wollongong52 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Maitland14 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Albury11 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Coffs Harbour10 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Port Macquarie10 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Nowra8 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Bathurst8 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Orange7 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Wagga Wagga7 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Tamworth7 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Bowral7 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Dubbo6 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Lismore5 ranked
- Pizza Restaurants in Byron Bay5 ranked
Ratings and review counts are Google's, as listed in October 2026. Phone numbers, websites and opening hours are the ones each business lists. Nothing here is paid for or verified by Calso. How the ranking works.