Skip to content
Sign up

Newcastle, New South Wales · October 2026 figures

Compare the top 10 Italian restaurants in Newcastle, NSW

Of the top 10, Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, Honeysuckle has the most reviews (1,334), and Vero Sapore Italiano Ristorante has the highest average (4.9 from 23 reviews). Casa Nova Italian Restaurant and Bar Toronto lists the most opening hours of the 10 (76.5 a week).

The top 10 Italian restaurants in Newcastle, side by side
RankBusinessRatingReviewsRating floorDays openSaturdaySundayOpen latePhoneWebsite
1Sapori at TailorsIslington4.8298Floor 4.716YesYesYes(02) 4962 3110none listed
2Pescara RestaurantPokolbin4.8270Floor 4.705YesYesYes0435 730 220pescara.com.au
3Osteria Papazzo, Caffe' Cucina & VinoNewcastle4.8184Floor 4.685YesNoNo0401 841 401osteriapapazzo.com
4Emilio’s Ristorante The JunctionThe Junction4.7551Floor 4.636YesYesYes(02) 4940 8883emiliositalian.com.au
5Vero Sapore Italiano RistoranteWickham4.923Floor 4.567YesYesYes0412 722 214verosaporewickham.com.au
6Emilio’s Ristorante Warners BayWarners Bay4.51,021Floor 4.456YesYesYes(02) 4947 1896emiliositalian.com.au
7Bella ItaliaNewcastle West4.5956Floor 4.457YesYesYes(02) 4927 8050bellaitaliaristorante.com.au/menu
8Don Beppino's RestaurantMerewether4.5462Floor 4.426YesNoNo(02) 4963 3969donbeppinos.com.au
9Casa Nova Italian Restaurant & Bar, HoneysuckleNewcastle4.41,334Floor 4.367YesYesYes(02) 4989 9795casanovaitalian.com.au/italian-restaurant-honeysuckle
10Casa Nova Italian Restaurant and Bar TorontoToronto4.41,158Floor 4.357YesYesYes(02) 4959 2722casanovaitalian.com.au

See all 18 ranked

More in Newcastle

Italian Restaurants elsewhere in New South Wales

Ratings and review counts are Google's, as listed in October 2026. Phone numbers, websites and opening hours are the ones each business lists. Nothing here is paid for or verified by Calso. How the ranking works.